Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995
Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan
For a very good overview of the various types of steel in todays terminology activate the link
You may also want to check the following modules of the Hyperscript
Damascene Technique in Metal Working
A commented Internet literature list to the history of metal working
| These are my personal notes, reflecting my major points of interest while perusing the Internet
data in May 2000. I may update them occasionally. You are welcome to share these notes with me, but I cannot guarantee for their scientific soundness (in contrast to almost everything else in this Hyperscript). |
|
Bloom | |
|
The iron-rich spongy stuff left over after smelting iron ore at temperatures of roughly (1100 - 1200)oC
- well below the melting point of (pure) iron of 1550oC. Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Cast iron | |
|
Everything with more than about 2% C content; low melting point of 1100oC (eutectic
composition) to 1200oC, depending on the C conc. Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
First produced in China. Short history including furnace design: Early progress in the Melting of iron by V.H.Patterson and M.J.Lalich | |
|
China and steel | |
|
First producers of cast iron; but seem to have used it mostly for agricultural and home keeping equipment
"on a very large scale". (Now here you have really cultured people!) Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Produced cast iron 800 - 700 BC Early progress in the Melting of iron by V.H.Patterson and M.J.Lalich | |
|
Damascus steel and blades | |
|
Something made from 330 BC on from wootz steel (and only from wootz steel, i.e. not with forge welding
two kinds of steel). Shows "swirl coloration" and is of "amazing strength and toughness". "Could be bent at right angles and still snap back" Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Source for Damascus steel was wootz steel; modern reconstruction yields blades with superplasticity (?). "One blow of a Damascus sword would cleave a European helmet without turning the edge or cut through a silk handkerchief drawn across it" (from the crusades) Blades have "water pattern... whose wavy streaks are glistening - it is like a pond on whose surface the wind is gliding" (from a 6th century writer). Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
"Wootz" is the true Damascus steel. Damascus Steel - A Brief History by Motoyasu. (Edited by WarAngel) | |
|
The term Damascus steel can refer to two different types of artifacts, one of which is the true Damascus
steel from wootz steel (with the water pattern) and the other is a composite structure. The mechanical properties of the traditional Damascus blades and the degree of exploitation of the unique properties of the steel are less well understood. Comments on the major paper of Verhoeven et al. Wootz steel: An Advanced Material of the Ancient World by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Two types from before 500 AD: "Normal" (two kinds of steel) and "oriental"
(or otherwise "true") Damascus from wootz steel. Pattern from alignments of Fe3C particles Last high-quality blade produced around 1750; even low-quality stopped in early 1900. Highest quality wootz blades from 16th- 17th century. Chemical analysis of old blades. Reproduces "Mohammeds latter" Note "It is relatively easy to make an ingot that will not pattern on forging" Art was lost because change in impurity content of wootz (no more V traces)? The Key Role of Impurities in Ancient Damascus Steel Blades by J.D. Verhoeven, A.H. Pendray, and W.E. Dauksch | |
|
Verhoeven summarized his findings in an Scientific Aerican article in Jan 2001 (The Mystery of Damascus Blades, John D. Verhoeven Essentially; Verhoeven together with the black smith Pendray could reproduce "true" damascus including specific patterns. | |
|
The Romans were not impressed by the (early forge welded) blades of the Celtic tribes (they bent easily
and broke). (Folded) Damascus steel is far superior to homogeneous (ancient) iron, but inferior to good homogeneous steel. The Road to Damascus - Sorting Modern Pattern Welding from Myth and Legend by Kevin R. Cashen | |
|
Third technique to create Damascus blades (immersion of a wrought iron package in liquid cast iron) Story of Saladin and Richard Lion-Heart) True Damascus steel was no longer produced after the Tartar conqueror Timur Leng raided the city in the 14th century and took all blacksmith with him Watered steel, wootz and true Damascus, by Lord Mikal Isernfocar called Ironhawk | |
|
In the 7th century the Syrians in Damascus came up with their own version of wootz steel Damascus sword of later times in forging two-metals-technique. "Hummels" book | |
|
Defects and steel | |
|
Relationship between iron and steel (the role of carbon) first described by Torben Bergman
1781 in his "Disseratatio Chemica de Analysi Ferri". Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Relationship between iron and steel (the role if carbon) first described by Torben Bergman 1774 Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Ferrosilicon introduced around 1810 Early progress in the Melting of iron by V.H.Patterson and M.J.Lalich | |
|
Relationship between iron and steel (the role if carbon) first described by the Swedish chemist Torben
Bergman 1774. The carbide banding mechanism (forming the water pattern in Damascus blades) was found to be assisted by the addition of P, S along with V, Cr, and Ti. Wootz steel: A Advanced Material of the Ancient World by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
The type of impurity elements (especially V and Mn besides C) in the wootz steel is
the most decisive element for true Damascus blades. True damascene depended on trace impurities. It may have be decisive were the ore came from! The Key Role of Impurities in Ancient Damascus Steel Blades by J.D. Verhoeven, A.H. Pendray, and W.E. Dauksch | |
|
Could W (tungsten) have played a role in true Damascus steel? Watered steel, wootz and true Damascus, by Lord Mikal Isernfocar called Ironhawk | |
|
Europe (after the Romans) and steel | |
|
Significant progress only in late medieval times; due to the use of coal for improved blast processes Relationship between iron and steel (the role if carbon) first described by Torben Bergman in 1781 in his "Disseratatio Chemica de Analysi Ferri". Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Development from the Catalan forge (8th century) on: Early progress in the Melting of iron by V.H.Patterson and M.J.Lalich | |
|
Description of the diverse periods (Bronze, Hallstatt, La Tene, Celtic, ...) and their swords. From Rapier to Langsax - Sword Structure in the British Isles in the Bronze and Iron Age by Niko Silvester | |
|
British, French and Russian metallography developed largely due to the quest to document this structure
(water pattern in Damascus blades from wootz steel). Wootz steel: A Advanced Material of the Ancient World by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Invention of the Catalan furnace was the end of ancient pattern welding (but came back later in an effort
to emulate "true" Damascus steel?). The Road to Damascus - Sorting Modern Pattern Welding from Myth and Legend by Kevin R. Cashen | |
|
Highly developed pattern welding technology in Europe from about 3rd to 5th century AD. The Serpent in the Sword: Pattern-welding in Early Medieval Swords by Lee A. Jones | |
|
Toledo was the center of steelmaking from pre-roman times! Repeats what my
smith told me. I have no idea about how much of it is halfway accurate. History of Swords from Toledo from some tourist agency | |
|
Japan and steel | |
|
In Japan, around 600 A.D., smelting technology was introduced from China and Korea. The Japanese
speciality was the mass production of (impure) steel, which was folded so many times and forge welded again that all the
impurities were driven out of the steel and the carbon became as evenly distributed as modern steels we have today. Damascus Steel - A Brief History by Motoyasu. (Edited by WarAngel) | |
|
"Tamahagane" steel from selecting suitable pieces from a bloom; much folding and hammering homogenized
and carburized the steel. The Road to Damascus - Sorting Modern Pattern Welding from Myth and Legend by Kevin R. Cashen | |
|
Some Japanese samurai had their swords made in Toledo! History of Swords from Toledo from some tourist agency | |
|
There are many ways to compose a Japanes sword from different types of steel. Japanese Sword: Blade lamination methods |
|
|
Hittites and steel | |
|
First culture to produce iron (wrought iron?) in quantities ; about 1500 BC. Had a monopoly for
some time. Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Hittites vanished into oblivion around 1200 BC, being overrun by the "sea people". This
may have caused the scattering of the iron working skills throughout the Mediterranean. "Hummels" book | |
|
Pattern welding | |
|
Pattern welding is about as old as iron and steel. Vikings were best at it (500 AD). Pattern welding in the West fell into disuse (around 1000 AD, when full steel blades could be made) until around the time of the Crusades, when the knights brought back Wootz blades, and the smiths began pattern welding again to duplicate the appearance of the watering patterns found on Wootz Damascus blades. This seems to be the reason for the wrong assumptions that Damascus blades were obtained by forging together two kinds of steel. Damascus Steel - A Brief History by Motoyasu. (Edited by WarAngel ) | |
|
Relatively primitive before 500 AD; but used by the Celts much earlier. The trick was (among many
things) the twisting of the single rods. Later it became an art form (around 1000 AD). Pattern not necessarily due to difference in C content (homogenizes considerably), but other impurities, mainly P. The Road to Damascus - Sorting Modern Pattern Welding from Myth and Legend by Kevin R. Cashen | |
|
Pattern welding from 3rd - 10th century; before that more simple techniques; zenith in the 6th and
7th century Patterns due to different kinds of iron, not necessarily only in C content, could be P or slag or whatever. Started for better quality, in the end purely decorative. Many swords with names of maker, but counterfeiting must have been rampant! The Serpent in the Sword: Pattern-welding in Early Medieval Swords by Lee A. Jones | |
|
The Romans used pattern welding. Patter welding used less by around the 9th century. From Rapier to Langsax - Sword Structure in the British Isles in the Bronze and Iron Age by Niko Silvester | |
|
Recent issues; open points and contradictions | |
|
Can you get "good" steel by roasting wrought iron in a charcoal fire?. J. Rehder 1989 said you can't, but D. B. Wagner in 1990 shows that you can. | |
|
Is wootz steel (or Damascus blades) showing superplastic properties or shatters on impact at high temperatures? It is all a matter of having the temperature right! | |
|
Did anybody in modern times ever made a blade which could be bent at right angles (or tried with an ancient blade)? Not mentioned anywhere. | |
|
Was the art of damascene technique lost? Certainly not the two-steel folding kind; possibly the true (wootz) kind. | |
|
How about true Damascus from soaking bundles of wrought iron (or mild steel) in molten cast iron? | |
|
Was W (tungsten) important in creating true Damascus blades? | |
|
When did true Damascus disappear? In the 14th century or around 1750? | |
|
Did the Romans use pattern welding? Why were their swords superior to the (pattern welded?) swords of the "Franks"? | |
|
What really happened in Toledo before the 7th century or so? | |
|
Toledo and steel | |
|
About 1000 AD, a form of this technology (= Wootz) made its way up via the Moors to Spain - this
technology allowed the Spanish smiths to create small amounts of smelted steel, which vastly improved the quality of their
blades (this is the origin of the reputation of Spain, and the city of Toledo in particular, for manufacture of high quality
blades - far better then the pattern welded blades.). Damascus Steel - A Brief History by Motoyasu. (Edited by WarAngel ) | |
|
Invention of Catalan furnace crucial to development of steel technology in Europe. The Road to Damascus - Sorting Modern Pattern Welding from Myth and Legend by Kevin R. Cashen | |
|
The Catalan furnace, invented in 1300, produced enough good steel and pattern welded blades went
rapidly out of style. Watered steel, wootz and true Damascus, by Lord Mikal Isernfocar called Ironhawk | |
|
In the 7th century the Spaniards in Toledo came up with their own version of wootz steel "Hummels" book | |
|
"There are stories of how the wrought iron swords of the Gauls bent during their battles against the
Romans legions armed with Toledo steel blades, which were <<so keen that there is no helmet that cannot be
cut by them>>. The hapless Gauls had to stop and straigthen their blades after each blow before continuiung fighting" "Sass'" book, p. 96. | |
|
Wootz steel | |
|
Carbon rich steel produced on a consistent base in India from about 330 BC up to the renaissance.
Two methods are quoted. Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A. Ginzel 1995 | |
|
Anglized version of "ukku", denoting steel Still exported to Europe, China, the Arab world and the Middle East in the 12th century (and supposedly still a secret). Source for Damascus blades with "water pattern". Played a major role to the development of metallurgy (together with the "secret" of Damascus steel). Everybody in the 19th century, it seems (incl. Michael Faraday), tried to figure out what it was and how it was made. Was the first "advanced" material, used in three continents for well over a millennium - unparalleled by anything else. Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Wootz was (the source of) the true Damascus. Damascus Steel - A Brief History by Motoyasu. (Edited by WarAngel ) | |
|
Superplasticity and other mechanical properties of wootz steel.
"Superplastic material essentially comprise a two-phase material of spherical grains of extremely fine grain size of
not more than 5 microns at the working temperature". Details on production techniques. High tech material of the ancient world. Wootz steel: A Advanced Material of the Ancient World by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
|
Wrought iron | |
|
"What you get upon pounding the bloom. Relatively pure iron. Soft, easy to weld, cannot be hardened.
Around since about 1500 BC. Steel in Ancient Greece and Rome by: E.A.Ginzel 1995 Metallurgical Heritage of India by S. Srinivasan and S. Ranganathan | |
Damascene Technique in Metal Working
Internet Literature to Damascene (and Other) Techniques in the Production of Iron and Steel
© H. Föll (Defects - Script)
With frame